- Guides
- Protective put
The protective put, explained
A protective put is insurance for a stock you own. You buy one put option for every 100 shares, which gives you the right to sell them at a fixed price until the put expires. However far the stock falls, your loss stops at that price plus what you paid for the put, and you keep all of the upside.
By the Stillwater teamLast updated Reviewed 11 min read
Key takeaways
- One put protects 100 shares. Its strike is the lowest price you can be forced to accept until expiration.
- You pay a premium up front, whether or not you end up needing the protection.
- Max loss = purchase price − put strike + premium. Breakeven = purchase price + premium.
- Unlike a collar or a covered call, a protective put leaves your upside uncapped.
- A put is more reliable than a stop-loss in a gap down, but it costs money and it expires.
- Options involve risk and are not suitable for every investor.
On this page
How a protective put works
A put option is the right, but not the obligation, to sell 100 shares at its strike price until expiration. When you own the shares and buy the put, the two positions offset each other below the strike: every dollar the stock loses under the strike, the put gains.
It works like home insurance. The premium is what you pay for the policy. The distance from today’s price down to the strike is your deductible: you absorb that part of a fall yourself. The expiration date is when the policy runs out. And if nothing bad happens, the premium is simply spent, the same way an insurance premium is.
When you buy the shares and the put on the same day, the position is often called a married put. The mechanics are identical.
Choosing the strike
The strike decides how much of a fall you take yourself before the put starts working. A put close to today’s price protects more and costs more; a put further out of the money is cheaper but leaves a bigger deductible. Here is the trade-off on a $50 stock with 60-day puts, using illustrative premiums.
| Put strike | Where | Premium | Max loss | Breakeven |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $50.00 | At the money | $2.60 | −$260 | $52.60 |
| $47.50 | 5% below | $1.70 | −$420 | $51.70 |
| $45.00 | 10% below | $1.20 | −$620 | $51.20 |
| $42.50 | 15% below | $0.80 | −$830 | $50.80 |
The cheapest put is not the cheapest protection: the $42.50 put costs least but lets you lose the most. A practical way to choose is to decide the largest loss you could accept on this position, then pick the strike that stops it there once the premium is counted.
Choosing the expiration
A put’s price is mostly time value, and time value does not grow in a straight line. A put lasting four times as long typically costs only about twice as much, so longer protection is usually cheaper per month. Shorter puts lose value fastest in their final weeks.
- One to two months suits protection around a specific event, such as an earnings report, or a short period of worry.
- Three months to a year or more suits ongoing protection on a position you plan to hold, at a lower cost per month and with fewer decisions.
- Check the calendar. If earnings fall before expiration, the put will be priced for that risk. That is often exactly when you want it.
- Check liquidity. Prefer strikes and expirations with tight bid-ask spreads; on thinly traded options the spread alone can be a large share of the cost.
Floor and breakeven
At expiration, a protective put’s profit and loss is flat below the strike and rises one for one above it. Two formulas describe it, per share; multiply by 100 for each contract.
Max loss= purchase price − put strike + premium
Breakeven= purchase price + premium
Max gain= unlimited, less the premium
A worked example
The numbers match the example in the options collar guide, so you can compare the two directly. Every figure is illustrative.
- The stock
- Buy 100 shares at $50.00
- $5,000 invested
- The put
- Buy one 60-day $45 put at $1.20
- $120 paid
- Not included
- Commissions, fees, dividends and taxes
Max loss = 50 − 45 + 1.20 = $6.20 × 100 = −$620
Breakeven = 50 + 1.20 = $51.20
The put costs $120, or 2.4% of the position, for two months of protection. In return, the most you can lose before it expires is $620 (12.4%), even if the stock halves overnight. Here is the position at several prices on expiration day, next to owning the shares alone.
| Price at expiration | Stock alone | With the put | What happens |
|---|---|---|---|
| $35 | −$1,500 | −$620 | Put in the money: sell at $45, or sell the put |
| $40 | −$1,000 | −$620 | Put in the money: the floor holds |
| $45 | −$500 | −$620 | Put expires worthless; the loss is at its largest |
| $48 | −$200 | −$320 | Put expires; you keep the shares |
| $51.20 | +$120 | $0 | Breakeven |
| $55 | +$500 | +$380 | Put expires; you keep the gain, less the premium |
| $65 | +$1,500 | +$1,380 | Put expires; upside is not capped |
Two months of protection at 2.4% is reasonable for a stretch you are worried about. Renewed six times a year at the same price, it would cost more than 14% a year, which is more than most stocks gain. That is why few investors hold puts continuously, and why many pay for them by selling a call.
Try it with your own stock and quotes in the free protective put calculator.
What happens at expiration
Below the strike: the put pays
The put is in the money. You can let it be exercised and sell your shares at the strike, or sell the put for its value and keep the shares. Options that finish in the money by $0.01 or more are normally exercised automatically, so if you want to keep your shares, sell the put or tell your broker before the close.
Above the strike: the put expires worthless
You keep your shares and every dollar of gain, less the premium. From that point you are unprotected unless you buy a new put or roll to a later one.
Protective put vs. stop-loss order
A stop-loss order is the free alternative, and for many positions it is enough. The difference shows up on bad days.
| Protective put | Stop-loss order | |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | The premium, paid whether or not it is needed | None until it triggers |
| Overnight gap down | Still sells at the strike | Fills at the next price, which can be far below the stop |
| Brief dip, then recovery | You keep your shares and the put | You may be sold out at the low |
| How long it lasts | Until the put expires | Until you cancel it, depending on the order type |
| Taxes | No sale unless you exercise | A triggered stop is a sale |
The SEC’s investor bulletin puts it plainly: once a stop price is reached, a stop order becomes a market order, and the execution price can differ significantly from the stop price in a fast-moving market. If the risk you are worried about is an earnings miss or overnight news, a put is the tool that actually holds its price.
Making protection cheaper
- Accept a bigger deductible. A strike further below the price costs less, as the strike table shows.
- Buy more time. Longer puts usually cost less per month of protection.
- Protect only part of the position. Two puts on 300 shares protects two-thirds of it.
- Sell a call to pay for it. Selling a call above the price brings in a premium that can cover most or all of the put. The catch is a cap on your upside. That combination is an options collar, and the call on its own is a covered call.
When a protective put fits
It can fit when
- You want to stay invested but a large fall would really hurt.
- A known event, such as earnings, could gap the stock.
- You want protection without giving up any upside.
- Selling now would trigger a tax bill you would rather defer.
It usually does not fit when
- You want protection all year: renewing puts gets expensive.
- You hold fewer than 100 shares.
- The options are thinly traded, so the spread eats the value.
- You would accept a capped upside for cheaper protection: a collar may fit better.
For other ways to protect a position, including selling part of it, see how to protect stock gains without selling.
Risks and limitations
- The premium is usually lost. Most of the time the stock does not fall far enough for the put to pay, and the premium is spent.
- Losses down to the strike are yours, plus the premium.
- Protection expires. After expiration you are unhedged unless you buy again, at whatever price puts cost then.
- Volatility raises the price. Puts cost the most when the market is already worried, which is often when people want them.
- Taxes. Buying a put on shares you have held for a year or less can affect their holding period in some cases. Talk to a tax professional.
- Suitability. Options require broker approval and are not suitable for every investor. Read the Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options before you trade.
How Stillwater uses puts
Stillwater prices protection before you buy. Every trading morning it shortlists a few stocks and, for each one, works out a put to buy and a call to sell from the live option chain, with the net cost, the floor and the cap, so you can see the most you could lose before you place a trade in your own brokerage account. See what a trading morning looks like.
Glossary
- Contract
- One listed option. A standard US stock option contract covers 100 shares, which is why collars are built in 100-share lots.
- Exercise
- Using an option: buying the shares at the strike with a call, or selling them at the strike with a put. At expiration, options that finish in the money by $0.01 or more are normally exercised automatically unless the owner tells their broker otherwise.
- Expiration
- The last day an option exists. Standard monthly US stock options expire on the third Friday of the month, and many stocks also list weekly expirations. After expiration the option either has been exercised or is gone.
- Floor
- In a protective put or a collar, the put strike: the lowest price at which you can sell your shares until the put expires. Your largest loss is the distance from your purchase price down to the floor, plus any net premium paid.
- Implied volatility
- How much the market expects a stock to move, worked backwards from option prices and stated as an annual percentage. Higher implied volatility makes every option on the stock more expensive: the put you buy and the call you sell.
- In the money
- An option that would be worth something if it expired right now: a put with a strike above the stock price, or a call with a strike below it. That built-in amount is its intrinsic value.
- Intrinsic value
- What an option would be worth if exercised right now: the stock price minus the strike for a call, or the strike minus the stock price for a put, and never less than zero. Whatever the option costs above that is time value.
- Out of the money
- An option that would be worthless if it expired right now: a put with a strike below the stock price, or a call with a strike above it. Collars normally use an out-of-the-money put and an out-of-the-money call.
- Protective put
- Buying one put for every 100 shares you own. It sets a minimum sale price, the strike, until the put expires, and keeps all of the upside above it, less the premium paid. It is sometimes called a married put when the shares and the put are bought together.
- Put option
- The right, but not the obligation, to sell 100 shares at the strike price until the option expires. Owning a put on shares you hold sets a minimum sale price for them.
- Rolling
- Closing an option you hold or sold and opening a similar one with a different strike, a later expiration, or both, usually as a single order.
- Stop-loss order
- An order to sell once the stock trades at or below a price you set. It then becomes a market order, so in a fast drop or an overnight gap it can fill well below your stop. It costs nothing until it is triggered.
- Strike price
- The fixed price at which an option lets its owner buy (a call) or sell (a put) the shares. In a collar, the put strike is your floor and the call strike is your cap.
- Time value
- The part of an option’s price above its intrinsic value: what buyers pay for the chance the stock moves before expiration. It shrinks as expiration approaches, faster in the final weeks, and is zero at expiration.
Common questions about protective puts
What is a protective put in simple terms?
It is insurance for a stock you own. You buy one put option for every 100 shares, which gives you the right to sell them at a set price, the strike, until the put expires. If the stock falls below the strike, the put makes up the difference. If it does not, you lose only what you paid for the put.
Is a protective put the same as a married put?
The payoff is the same. A married put is the name used when you buy the shares and the put at the same time; a protective put usually means adding a put to shares you already own.
How much does a protective put cost?
It depends on the stock’s implied volatility, how close the strike is to the price and how long the put lasts. A put a few percent below the price lasting one to three months often costs somewhere between about one and five percent of the stock’s value, and more for volatile stocks or around earnings.
What is the maximum loss with a protective put?
The purchase price minus the put strike, plus the premium paid, for each share. In the example on this page that is $50 − $45 + $1.20 = $6.20 a share, or $620 for 100 shares, however far the stock falls before the put expires.
Is a protective put better than a stop-loss order?
It is more reliable but not free. A stop-loss costs nothing until it triggers, but it becomes a market order and can fill far below the stop in a gap. A put guarantees its strike until expiration, but you pay a premium whether or not you need it.
How can I make a protective put cheaper?
Choose a strike further below the price, accept a shorter or longer expiration that costs less per month, or sell a call above the price to pay for the put. Selling the call turns the position into a collar, which caps your upside in exchange.
Sources and further reading
- Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options, The Options Clearing Corporation
- Options, Investor.gov, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
- Investor Bulletin: Stop, stop-limit and trailing stop orders, Investor.gov, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
- Options assignment FAQ, Options Industry Council
- Protective put: what it is, how it works and examples, Fidelity Investments Canada
This guide explains how protective puts work. It is education, not a recommendation to buy or sell any security, and not tax or legal advice. Read Stillwater’s disclosures.