What you need to know
Last updated
This kind of position is often called a collar. The long put sets a floor price at which you can sell your shares until the put expires. The short call caps your upside at its strike price in exchange for the premium you receive.
Stillwater is an educational service. We show you how we trade and why. We do not know your finances, goals or risk tolerance, and nothing we publish is a recommendation that you buy or sell any security.
Before you start
You need a margin account approved for advanced options trading, funded with at least $50,000.
- Open a margin account. A cash account will not support the system as we trade it. Your broker will ask you to sign a margin agreement; read it, especially the sections on margin calls and forced sales.
- Get options approval at Level 3, or preferably Level 4. Brokers number their levels differently. What matters is that you are approved for spreads, covered calls and uncovered (naked) calls. Uncovered calls usually require a broker’s highest level. That approval lets you keep a call open for a short time if your stock is sold first, for example when your put is exercised. It is a safety margin, not part of the method. We do not recommend holding naked calls. Ask your broker which level covers each type of trade on this site.
- Fund the account with $50,000. This lets you hold several positions at once and absorb a loss without a margin call. Our own account started at $100,000, so a $50,000 account will hold fewer or smaller positions than you see in our results.
- Read the Options Disclosure Document. Your broker must give you Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options before approving you for options. It explains exercise, assignment and expiration in detail.
- Know your costs. Commissions, per-contract fees and margin interest reduce your returns. Our posted results include commissions; margin interest depends on your broker and balance.
Managing your positions
Your protection ends the day your put expires, so every position needs a decision before that date.
- Check the Stillwater account to learn how we manage open positions: when we roll puts, buy back calls and close trades.
- Monitor every position, and watch put expiration dates most closely. Keep a list of your puts by expiration date. Review each position at least a week before its put expires.
Keep “available for withdrawal” at 25% to 30% of net account value
Watch your margin balance. In our brokerage account, the amount shown as available for withdrawal is the cushion we track. On a $50,000 account, that means keeping roughly $12,500 to $15,000 available. Check it before every new trade. If a trade would push the amount below 25% of net account value, skip it or make it smaller. Too many open positions at once is the most common way to fall below that level. Staying above it leaves room to absorb a drop, pay for new puts when you roll, and avoid a margin call.
Before adding a trade, look ahead two weeks. Add up the likely cost of rolling every put that expires in that window. Make sure you would still be above 25% after paying for those rolls and the new trade.
If available for withdrawal falls below 25%
Whether from new trades or from a market drop, act in this order:
- Stop opening new positions until you are back above 25%.
- Keep your protection. Never sell a put to raise cash while you still own the stock.
- Close a whole position, not part of one. Sell the stock, buy back the call, and sell the put in the same session. Good candidates:
- A position trading below its put strike. The put has gained value, so closing it frees cash at the floor you planned for.
- Your largest position. Closing it frees the most margin in one step.
- A position with a put expiring soon that you would otherwise pay to roll.
- Or reduce a position. If you hold more than 100 shares, sell 100 shares together with one put and one call.
- Or add cash to the account.
Act faster the further below 25% you fall. If your broker issues a margin call, meet it the same day. Otherwise the broker can sell positions for you, and it may sell the stock and leave a call uncovered.
What happens at put expiration
It depends on where the stock closes:
| Stock at put expiration | What happens to the put | Where that leaves you | Your choices |
|---|---|---|---|
| Above the put strike | Expires worthless | You still own the stock and the short call, but have no downside protection |
|
| Below the put strike | Usually exercised automatically; your shares are sold at the strike price | The stock is gone but the short call is still open, now uncovered |
|
Never leave a naked call open. An uncovered short call has unlimited loss if the stock rises. Whenever you sell the stock, or your put is exercised, close the call the same day.
Watch the other legs too:
- Early assignment. A short call can be assigned before expiration, especially just before an ex-dividend date. Your shares are then sold at the call strike, and you still hold the put.
- Rolling costs money. A new put costs premium each time. Track what protection costs you over a year, not just one trade.
If you trade collars in a smaller account
The small-account version uses the same collar on lower-priced stocks, so one position is 100 shares and about $2,000. The bought put keeps the same floor under every position. How collars for smaller accounts work.
- Check that it fits your account. It is for a margin account with at least $25,000 in cash available, or for building collars on stocks you already own.
- Keep positions small and few. Trade 100 shares a collar and hold no more than about eight at a time. Keep spare cash in the account rather than adding shares to a position.
- Manage it like the main account. Roll the put up after a rise, buy the call back on dips and sell it again on rises, and sell the shares when the position is profitable.
- Expect quiet days. With these price and size limits, some mornings have few candidates or none. Strikes on lower-priced stocks come in $0.50 or $1 steps, so the put may sit a little further below the price than on the main list.
Important warnings
You can lose money with this system, including on positions that are fully protected.
- A protective put does not prevent losses. Used properly, it defines and limits them. If you buy a put with a strike below your purchase price, the gap between the two, plus the put’s cost, is a loss you have accepted in advance. Example: stock bought at $267 with a $240 put has a floor about $27 a share below cost, before premiums.
- All of our posted results use margin. We borrow against our account to hold more stock than our cash alone would buy. At times our stock holdings have been close to twice our account equity. Margin magnifies gains and losses alike, and you pay interest on the loan. If you don’t use margin, your results won’t be the same.
- Margin calls can force sales. If your equity falls below your broker’s requirement, the broker can sell your positions without asking, at a time and price you do not choose. Brokers can raise their requirements without notice.
- Protection lapses at expiration. Between one put expiring and the next being bought, you hold unprotected stock. Prices can also gap overnight or over a weekend.
- The upside is capped. If a stock rises well above your call strike, you give up the gain above that strike, or pay to buy the call back.
- Options can be hard to trade. Wide bid-ask spreads, thin volume and fast markets can make fills worse than the prices you see.
- Taxes are complicated. Puts, calls, assignments and quick turnover can affect holding periods, wash-sale treatment and how gains are taxed. Talk to a tax adviser.
About our posted results
Our results come from a real brokerage account, traded with margin, and you should not expect to match them.
- Real trades, real account. Results are from Stillwater’s own account, which started with $100,000. Figures include commissions. They do not reflect margin interest unless stated. Every stock held in the account was a Stillwater pick, but not every Stillwater pick was traded.
- Margin is built in. These results use margin. If you don’t use margin, your results won’t be the same: the returns would be different, and the swings smaller, without borrowed money.
- The main account only. The account trades collars on the main list. Small-account collars on lower-priced stocks are not part of these results, and their results would differ.
- Your results will differ. Account size, timing, fill prices, fees, taxes and the trades you choose to take or skip all change your outcome.
- Short history. A few months of results says little about how the system performs over a full market cycle, including a sharp or prolonged decline.
- Past results do not predict future results. A system that has beaten the market can trail it, or lose money, in the next period.
Disclaimer
Stillwater Options, LLC publishes educational content about stock and options trading. It is not a registered investment adviser or broker-dealer, and it does not provide personalized investment, tax or legal advice.
Nothing on stillwateroptions.com is an offer, solicitation or recommendation to buy or sell any security or to adopt any strategy. Content is general and impersonal and is not tailored to any subscriber’s circumstances. Options and margin trading involve substantial risk and are not suitable for all investors. You can lose more than you invest.
Performance figures reflect a single account traded with margin over a limited period, and past performance does not guarantee future results. Stillwater, its partners and affiliates may hold positions in the securities discussed. You are solely responsible for your own trading decisions. Consult a licensed financial professional before trading. See also our disclosures and terms of service.