- Guides
- Covered call vs. collar
Covered calls explained, and how they compare with a collar
A covered call means selling a call option against shares you already own. You collect a premium now and, in exchange, agree to sell your shares at the strike price if the stock rises above it. It earns income and caps your upside, but it barely protects you if the stock falls. Adding a protective put turns it into a collar, which does.
By the Stillwater teamLast updated Reviewed 12 min read
Key takeaways
- A covered call is 100 shares plus one sold call above the price. The premium is yours to keep.
- Max gain = call strike − purchase price + premium. Breakeven = purchase price − premium.
- The premium is the only protection. Below the breakeven you lose almost as much as the stock does.
- A collar adds a bought put. It gives up most of the premium in exchange for a floor.
- Both cap your upside, and with both your shares can be called away, sometimes early.
- Options involve risk and are not suitable for every investor.
On this page
How a covered call works
A call option gives its owner the right to buy 100 shares at the strike price until expiration. When you sell one, you take the other side: you receive the premium up front and accept the obligation to sell your shares at the strike if the buyer exercises. The call is “covered” because you already own the shares you might have to deliver. Selling a call without the shares is a very different, far riskier trade.
Investors usually sell calls out of the money, above today’s price. If the stock stays below the strike, the call expires worthless and the premium is income. If the stock rises through it, your shares are sold at the strike and the gain above it goes to the buyer.
Choosing the strike
- Closer to the price brings in more premium, but caps your gain sooner and makes it more likely your shares are called away.
- Further above the price leaves more room to run, but pays less.
- A useful test: choose a strike at which you would be genuinely content to sell. If you would be upset to lose the shares there, the strike is too close.
Choosing the expiration
A call’s price is mostly time value, which decays fastest in the last few weeks before expiration. That is why many covered-call sellers favor expirations of one to two months and sell again when they expire. Longer calls pay more in total but less per month, and they fix your cap for longer. Check the calendar for earnings and ex-dividend dates before you pick a date.
Max gain and breakeven
Per share, at expiration; multiply by 100 for each contract.
Max gain= call strike − purchase price + premium
Breakeven= purchase price − premium
Max loss= breakeven, if the stock goes to zero
A worked example
The same stock and strikes as the options collar guide, so the two strategies can be compared line by line. Every figure is illustrative.
- The stock
- Buy 100 shares at $50.00
- $5,000 invested
- The call
- Sell one 60-day $57.50 call at $1.10
- $110 received
- For the collar
- Also buy one 60-day $45 put at $1.20
- $120 paid
- Not included
- Commissions, fees, dividends and taxes
Max gain = 57.50 − 50 + 1.10 = +$8.60 × 100 = +$860
Breakeven = 50 − 1.10 = $48.90
The $110 premium is 2.2% of the position for two months. It is income only if the stock does not fall by more than that. Here is the covered call at several prices on expiration day, next to the shares alone and the collar.
| Price at expiration | Stock alone | Covered call | Collar |
|---|---|---|---|
| $35 | −$1,500 | −$1,390 | −$510 |
| $45 | −$500 | −$390 | −$510 |
| $48.90 | −$110 | $0 | −$120 |
| $50 | $0 | +$110 | −$10 |
| $55 | +$500 | +$610 | +$490 |
| $57.50 | +$750 | +$860 | +$740 |
| $65 | +$1,500 | +$860 | +$740 |
The covered call beats the collar by $120 at every price above the put strike: that is the put premium the collar spends. Below $45 the picture flips. At $35 the covered call has lost $1,390 and the collar $510, and the gap keeps widening the further the stock falls.
Try it with your own stock and quotes in the free covered call calculator.
Assignment and dividends
US stock options can be exercised on any business day, so a covered call can be assigned before expiration. It rarely happens while the call still has meaningful time value, with one common exception: just before an ex-dividend date, the owner of an in-the-money call may exercise to collect the dividend. Your shares are then sold at the strike and you do not receive that dividend.
If the stock climbs toward the strike and you want to keep the shares, you can buy the call back or roll it to a higher strike or later date. That usually costs money, because the call has gained value. Treat each roll as a new trade.
Covered call vs. collar
A collar is a covered call with a put added. Both cap the upside at the call strike. The difference is what happens to the call premium: the covered call keeps it as income, the collar spends it on a floor.
| Covered call | Collar | |
|---|---|---|
| What you hold | Shares and a sold call | Shares, a sold call and a bought put |
| Upfront | You receive the call premium | Roughly zero: the call pays for the put |
| Downside | Open, cushioned only by the premium | Limited at the put strike |
| Upside | Capped at the call strike | Capped at the call strike |
| Worked example: worst case | −$4,890 if the stock goes to zero | −$510 |
| Worked example: best case | +$860 | +$740 |
| If the stock is flat | You keep the $110 premium | About break-even: −$10 |
| Main purpose | Income from shares you hold | Protection at little or no cost |
Which one fits
A covered call can fit when
- You expect the stock to drift sideways or rise modestly.
- You would be content to sell at the strike.
- You could ride out a large fall without being forced to sell.
- Income matters more to you than protection.
A collar can fit when
- A large fall in this stock would really hurt.
- You want to know your worst case before you trade.
- You would trade the call premium for a floor.
- An event, such as earnings, could gap the stock down.
If you want the floor without the cap, a protective put on its own does that, at a higher cost. For a side-by-side of every approach, see how to protect stock gains without selling.
Risks and limitations
- Little downside protection. The premium cushions only the first few percent of a fall.
- Capped upside. In a sharp rally you keep only the move up to the strike.
- Early assignment, especially around ex-dividend dates, can end the position before you planned.
- Costs add up. Selling calls every month means paying a bid-ask spread and commissions each time.
- Taxes. Assignment is a sale, and the rules for qualified covered calls can affect holding periods and how losses are treated. Talk to a tax professional.
- Suitability. Options require broker approval and are not suitable for every investor. Read the Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options before you trade.
How Stillwater prices collars every morning
Stillwater is built around the collar. Every trading morning it shortlists a few stocks and, for each one, prices the call to sell and the put to buy from the live option chain, with the net cost, the floor and the cap. You decide whether to trade, in your own brokerage account. See what a trading morning looks like.
Glossary
- Assignment
- What happens to the seller when an option they sold is exercised. If your covered call is assigned, your shares are sold at the call strike. US stock options can be exercised on any business day before expiration, so assignment can come early.
- Breakeven
- The stock price at expiration where the whole position neither makes nor loses money: your purchase price plus any net debit, or minus any net credit, ignoring commissions.
- Call option
- The right, but not the obligation, to buy 100 shares at the strike price until the option expires. When you sell a call against shares you own, you take the other side: you may have to sell your shares at the strike.
- Cap
- In a covered call or a collar, the call strike: the most you will effectively receive for your shares until the call expires, because above it the call you sold gains value one-for-one with the stock.
- Collar
- A three-part position: 100 shares you own, a put bought below the stock price and a call sold above it. The put sets a floor, the call sets a cap, and the call premium pays for most or all of the put, so the most you can lose is known before the trade. In exchange you give up gains above the cap until expiration.
- Contract
- One listed option. A standard US stock option contract covers 100 shares, which is why collars are built in 100-share lots.
- Covered call
- Selling one call for every 100 shares you own. You keep the premium whatever happens, but you may have to sell your shares at the strike, so gains above it are given up. The premium cushions a small fall; it does not protect against a large one.
- Ex-dividend date
- The first day a stock trades without its next dividend. You must own the shares before this date to receive the payment, which is why in-the-money calls are sometimes exercised the day before.
- Expiration
- The last day an option exists. Standard monthly US stock options expire on the third Friday of the month, and many stocks also list weekly expirations. After expiration the option either has been exercised or is gone.
- In the money
- An option that would be worth something if it expired right now: a put with a strike above the stock price, or a call with a strike below it. That built-in amount is its intrinsic value.
- Out of the money
- An option that would be worthless if it expired right now: a put with a strike below the stock price, or a call with a strike above it. Collars normally use an out-of-the-money put and an out-of-the-money call.
- Put option
- The right, but not the obligation, to sell 100 shares at the strike price until the option expires. Owning a put on shares you hold sets a minimum sale price for them.
- Rolling
- Closing an option you hold or sold and opening a similar one with a different strike, a later expiration, or both, usually as a single order.
- Strike price
- The fixed price at which an option lets its owner buy (a call) or sell (a put) the shares. In a collar, the put strike is your floor and the call strike is your cap.
- Time value
- The part of an option’s price above its intrinsic value: what buyers pay for the chance the stock moves before expiration. It shrinks as expiration approaches, faster in the final weeks, and is zero at expiration.
Common questions about covered calls and collars
What is a covered call in simple terms?
You own at least 100 shares and sell someone the right to buy them from you at a higher price, the strike, until a set date. They pay you a premium now. If the stock ends above the strike you sell your shares at that price; if not, you keep the shares and the premium.
What is the difference between a covered call and a collar?
A collar is a covered call plus a protective put. Both cap your upside at the call strike. The covered call keeps the whole premium as income but leaves the downside open; the collar spends most or all of the premium on a put that sets a floor under the stock.
Does a covered call protect against losses?
Only by the amount of the premium. In the example on this page the premium is $1.10 a share, so the stock can fall to $48.90 before you lose money, but below that you lose almost as much as if you owned the shares alone.
What happens if the stock goes above the call strike?
Your shares will most likely be sold at the strike, either at expiration or earlier, and you keep the premium. That is the covered call’s maximum gain. You miss any rise above the strike, and the sale may be a taxable event.
Can I lose money on a covered call?
Yes. If the stock falls by more than the premium you received, the position loses money, and the loss can be most of the stock’s value. Selling the call does not limit the downside of the shares.
Is a covered call or a collar better?
Neither is better in general. A covered call suits a stock you are content to hold through a fall and want income from. A collar suits a stock where a large fall would really hurt, and you would rather spend the call premium on protection.
Sources and further reading
- What is a covered call?, Options Industry Council
- Collar (protective collar), Options Industry Council
- Options assignment FAQ, Options Industry Council
- Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options, The Options Clearing Corporation
- Options, Investor.gov, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
This guide explains how covered calls and collars work. It is education, not a recommendation to buy or sell any security, and not tax or legal advice. Read Stillwater’s disclosures.