- Guides
- Protect stock gains
How to protect stock gains without selling
To protect a gain in a stock you want to keep, you can set a stop-loss order, buy a protective put, or build a collar that pays for the put by selling a call. Each one trades something away: a stop-loss can fill far below its price in a gap, a put costs a premium, and a collar caps your upside. Trimming the position is the only way to remove the risk outright.
By the Stillwater teamLast updated Reviewed 12 min read
Key takeaways
- Every way of protecting a gain costs something: money, upside, ownership or certainty.
- A stop-loss is free but not guaranteed: in a gap it sells at the next available price.
- A protective put guarantees a sale price until it expires, for a premium.
- A collar sets the same floor for little or no cost by capping the upside.
- A covered call earns income but protects only by the premium.
- Hedges can have tax consequences. Talk to a tax professional before hedging a large gain.
On this page
Six ways, at a glance
- Stop-loss order
- Sell automatically if the price falls to your stop. Free until it triggers, but not a guaranteed price.
- Protective put
- Buy the right to sell at a fixed price until a set date. Keeps all the upside, costs a premium.
- Collar
- A protective put paid for by selling a call. The same floor for little or no cost, with a cap on the upside.
- Covered call
- Sell a call for income. Cushions a small fall, does not protect against a large one.
- Trim
- Sell part of the position. Removes risk on what you sell, keeps exposure on the rest, and may be taxable.
- Diversify
- Move gains into other holdings over time, so no single stock can do too much damage.
The example position
One position, used for every approach below. The option premiums are illustrative, not quotes.
- The shares
- 200 shares bought at $40, now $100
- $20,000 value
- The gain
- $60 a share unrealized
- $12,000 gain
- A put
- Buy two 3-month $90 puts at $3.00
- $600 paid
- A call
- Sell two 3-month $115 calls at $2.80
- $560 received
- Not included
- Commissions, fees, dividends and taxes
Compared on the same stock
How much of the $12,000 gain each approach keeps if the stock falls hard, and what it leaves you if the stock instead rises to $130, at the options’ expiration.
| Approach | Upfront cost | Gain kept in a fall | Gain if it rises to $130 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Do nothing | $0 | Falls with the stock; below $40 it is a loss | +$18,000 |
| Stop-loss at $90 | $0 | About +$10,000, less if it gaps below $90 | +$18,000 if never triggered |
| Protective put, $90 | $600 | +$9,400 guaranteed | +$17,400 |
| Collar, $90 / $115 | $40 | +$9,960 guaranteed | +$14,960 (capped) |
| Covered call, $115 | You receive $560 | Cushioned by $560 only | +$15,560 (capped) |
| Sell half now | Possible tax | +$6,000 locked on half; the rest falls with the stock | +$6,000 + $9,000 = +$15,000 |
The put keeps the most upside of the guaranteed approaches, the collar is the cheapest guaranteed floor, and the stop-loss is free but only as good as the next trade. The worked arithmetic for each is below.
Stop-loss orders
A stop-loss order at $90 sells all 200 shares once the stock trades there, keeping about ($90 − $40) × 200 = $10,000 of the gain. It costs nothing while it waits. The weakness is the gap: once triggered it becomes a market order, so if the stock opens at $75 after bad news, it sells near $75 and keeps about $7,000. It can also sell you out on a brief dip that recovers the same day, and a triggered stop is a taxable sale.
Protective puts
Two $90 puts at $3.00 cost $600 and guarantee a sale price of $90 until they expire, gap or no gap. The worst case keeps ($90 − $40) × 200 − $600 = $9,400 of the gain. If the stock rises to $130 you keep $18,000 − $600 = $17,400. The cost is the premium, and the protection lasts only three months. The protective put guide covers strikes, expirations and what happens at expiration.
Collars
Selling two $115 calls at $2.80 brings in $560, which pays for most of the $600 in puts. The collar costs a net debit of $40 and keeps at least $10,000 − $40 = $9,960 of the gain, whatever the stock does before expiration. The price is the cap: above $115 your shares are sold, so at $130 the gain is ($115 − $40) × 200 − $40 = $14,960. For a stock that has already run up, many investors find that a fair trade. The options collar guide explains how to choose the strikes.
Covered calls
Selling the $115 calls on their own brings in $560 of income, but that is the only protection: below $97.20 the position loses value almost as fast as the stock. If the stock rises to $130, the gain is capped at ($115 − $40) × 200 + $560 = $15,560. A covered call suits a stock you expect to drift, not one you are worried about. See covered calls compared with a collar.
Trimming and diversifying
Selling half the position locks in $6,000 of the gain for good and leaves 100 shares exposed to the stock, up or down. It is the most certain protection and the simplest, and it is also a sale, so in a taxable account it may create a tax bill this year. Many investors with a large gain in one stock combine the two: a collar or put to protect the whole position now, and gradual sales over several tax years to diversify.
A note on taxes: talk to a tax professional
Hedging does not by itself sell your shares, which is part of its appeal for a large unrealized gain. But the tax rules reach some hedges. A collar whose strikes are very close to the stock price can, in some cases, be treated as a constructive sale, as if you had sold. Puts can affect the holding period of shares held for a year or less. Assignment on a call and a triggered stop are both sales. This guide is not tax advice; before hedging a large gain, talk to a tax professional.
Choosing an approach
- You mostly worry about a slow decline and want no cost: a stop-loss may be enough.
- You worry about a gap, such as an earnings miss, and want all the upside: a protective put.
- You want a guaranteed floor at little cost and can live with a cap: a collar.
- You expect the stock to drift and want income: a covered call, knowing it does not protect much.
- The position is simply too big for your comfort: trim it, and hedge what is left.
- Whatever you choose, options require broker approval and are not suitable for every investor. Read the Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options before you trade.
How Stillwater helps
Stillwater does the collar arithmetic before the market opens. Every trading morning it shortlists a few stocks and prices a collar for each one from the live option chain, with the net cost, the floor and the cap, so you know the most you could lose before you trade in your own brokerage account. See what a trading morning looks like.
Glossary
- Call option
- The right, but not the obligation, to buy 100 shares at the strike price until the option expires. When you sell a call against shares you own, you take the other side: you may have to sell your shares at the strike.
- Collar
- A three-part position: 100 shares you own, a put bought below the stock price and a call sold above it. The put sets a floor, the call sets a cap, and the call premium pays for most or all of the put, so the most you can lose is known before the trade. In exchange you give up gains above the cap until expiration.
- Concentrated position
- A single stock that makes up a large share of your portfolio, often after years of gains or from company stock pay. Investors often hedge one with puts or a collar rather than sell, to limit the damage of a fall. Very tight collars on appreciated stock can be treated as a sale for tax purposes, so check with a tax professional.
- Covered call
- Selling one call for every 100 shares you own. You keep the premium whatever happens, but you may have to sell your shares at the strike, so gains above it are given up. The premium cushions a small fall; it does not protect against a large one.
- Expiration
- The last day an option exists. Standard monthly US stock options expire on the third Friday of the month, and many stocks also list weekly expirations. After expiration the option either has been exercised or is gone.
- Hedge
- A position taken to reduce the risk of another one. For a stock you own, a protective put or a collar is a hedge; a covered call is a partial one, since its premium offsets only a small fall. Every hedge costs something, either premium paid or upside given up.
- Implied volatility
- How much the market expects a stock to move, worked backwards from option prices and stated as an annual percentage. Higher implied volatility makes every option on the stock more expensive: the put you buy and the call you sell.
- Protective put
- Buying one put for every 100 shares you own. It sets a minimum sale price, the strike, until the put expires, and keeps all of the upside above it, less the premium paid. It is sometimes called a married put when the shares and the put are bought together.
- Put option
- The right, but not the obligation, to sell 100 shares at the strike price until the option expires. Owning a put on shares you hold sets a minimum sale price for them.
- Rolling
- Closing an option you hold or sold and opening a similar one with a different strike, a later expiration, or both, usually as a single order.
- Stop-loss order
- An order to sell once the stock trades at or below a price you set. It then becomes a market order, so in a fast drop or an overnight gap it can fill well below your stop. It costs nothing until it is triggered.
- Strike price
- The fixed price at which an option lets its owner buy (a call) or sell (a put) the shares. In a collar, the put strike is your floor and the call strike is your cap.
Common questions about protecting stock gains
How can I protect my stock gains without selling?
The main tools are a stop-loss order, which sells automatically if the price falls to a level you set; a protective put, which gives you the right to sell at a fixed price until it expires; and a collar, which pays for that put by selling a call and capping your upside. Trimming part of the position is the simplest option if a partial sale is acceptable.
What is the cheapest way to protect a stock position?
A stop-loss order costs nothing until it triggers, but it can fill well below your stop in a gap. Among options strategies, a collar is usually the cheapest because the call you sell pays for most or all of the put; the cost is the upside you give up above the call strike.
Do I have to pay taxes when I hedge a stock?
Hedging does not trigger a sale by itself, but some hedges have tax consequences. A stop-loss that triggers is a sale. A collar with strikes very close to the price can in some cases be treated as a constructive sale, and puts can affect holding periods. Talk to a tax professional before hedging a large gain.
What is the best way to hedge a concentrated stock position?
There is no single best way. Investors with a large gain in one stock often combine a hedge, such as a protective put or a collar, with a plan to diversify gradually over several tax years. A collar is common because it sets a floor at little or no upfront cost.
Can I lock in a stock gain completely?
Not without giving something up. A put locks in most of the gain for a premium; a collar locks it in for little or no cost but caps the upside; selling locks it in fully but ends your ownership and may be taxable. Each option costs either money, upside or ownership.
Sources and further reading
- Investor Bulletin: Stop, stop-limit and trailing stop orders, Investor.gov, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
- Collar (protective collar), Options Industry Council
- Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options, The Options Clearing Corporation
- Options, Investor.gov, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
- Protective option, Wikipedia
This guide explains how these hedges work. It is education, not a recommendation to buy or sell any security, and not tax or legal advice. Read Stillwater’s disclosures.